Disappointing, unbelievable, and anticlimactic. Those are the only words that capture the essence of The Last Echoes of the Lord of Bells (Book 7) by John Bierce. The narrator – Ralph Lister -was great! But even his excellent narration couldn’t save the story. This book is like taking a trip with a GPS that is constantly recalculating you and taking you to places you didn’t need to or want to go.
The great war that is anticipated between “the madman” (name withheld to prevent spoilers for people new to the series) and Hugh and his friends lasts from Chapter 27 to Chapter 71. This 44-chapter war is told from multiple characters’ perspective – the main characters, other characters from previous books (who you may or may not remember), and possibly even new characters. In all honesty, there were so many characters and perspectives involved in this book, I couldn’t keep them all straight.
I was thoroughly disappointed as I really enjoyed the first 5 books in the series. Other readers claimed that book 6 did not really accomplish or add anything plot-wise, and I agreed with them. However, I had hoped that book 7 would be a return to the story quality I had known and loved from the beginning. That, unfortunately, was not the case. I couldn’t even finish the book. I got so tired of the battles that I only made it to chapter 54. Then I skipped to chapter sixty-something hoping the war would be over. I was wrong. So, I skipped to chapter 71 which, thankfully, was the last chapter of the fight.
A lot of my opinion has to do with events in the story itself. However, those events contain spoilers. If you don’t mind spoilers, keep reading. Otherwise, stop here, and you can read the story and come to your own conclusions.
*** Spoiler Alert (Click to Expand) ***
Hugh and his friends start off fighting Alustin and Valiah. (I listened to the audiobook, so I’m not sure how the characters’ names are spelled.) Then, they join sides with Valiah to take down Alustin. During their entire fight with Alustin, they talk to him and try to convince him that his plan is going to destroy the entire world. And you know what? They do! So Alustin has this “change of heart” in the middle of the battle where he realizes his plan to release the Tongue Eater would destroy the entire continent and he decides to work with Valiah and Hugh and his friends to stop the Tongue Eater from being released. How totally unbelievable! How does the main villain for the last two books all of a sudden have a change of heart and try to stop his plan while working with the very people he tried to kill?
*** Major Spoiler (Click to Expand) ***
At the end of the book, they Alustin is executed which made me sad, but ultimately, I knew it was justified and the end result. I mean, how could anyone allow someone who caused that much destruction to go unpunished; his actions caused the deaths of not only Havath’s city and people, but many of Skyhold’s allies as well. As the story-wrap up continues, it turns out that Kanderon did not in fact execute Alustin. She only pretend to. Instead, she intends to use him for one of her other plans, which I thought, was completely outrageous and unbelievable. Alustin expressed no remorse for his actions; he admittedly tried to kill Kanderon several books ago, and now she thinks she can use him to carry out her plans? How long will it be before Alustin tries to escape or betray her again?